NewUsed

Find by category:

Exhaust Notes

BMW Working on 7-Speed Manual Without a Clutch Pedal

Patent drawings show a gearbox with an 'electromechanical shift actuator,' meaning it would require no driver skill to operate.

By Sam Smith Jun 8, 2012 4:41AM
2010 BMW M3. Image courtesy BMW.If recent patent drawings are any guide, BMW is planning to release a manual transmission with seven or more gears.

This is not so much news as a steppingstone to another, more interesting piece of information. This isn't the first 7-speed manual to be developed. Porsche offers a 7-speed manual in the 991-generation 911; it's the first gearbox of its type to be offered in a passenger car, but it is by no means revolutionary. Porsche's 7-speed is built up from the 7-speed used in its PDK twin-clutch automated transmission. If you're not familiar, PDK is the lightning-fast automatic transmission found in the 991. Versions of the technology also appear in other Porsche products. 

Porsche's manual is essentially a standard gearbox. Although it shares components with its PDK sibling, it uses a clutch pedal and requires a decent amount of skill for smooth operation. Seventh gear is located up and to the right from sixth gear; the gearbox has a clever mechanical lockout that keeps you from putting the lever in seventh unless you're coming directly from sixth. It's compact and simple, and simply works. 

BMW's approach is different. It's simpler at first glance, but it's also far more complex. Are you ready for a manual transmission without a clutch pedal?
  
Porsche 7-speed manual. Image courtesy Porsche.Above: Porsche's 7-speed manual shift lever. Seventh gear is directly to the right of fifth. It's unreachable from any gear other than sixth due to an automatic lockout. 

Before we go any further, it's best to keep in mind that patent applications are not reality. Most patents, even those from carmakers, don't see the light of engineering day. The United States Patent Office, for example, issues more than 150,000 patents per year to individuals and companies worldwide, and only a fraction of those are ever brought to production.

Still, what we have here is pretty cool. Take a moment and read E90Post's look at the patent drawings. The drawings themselves are reproduced below, along with E90Post's annotations. 
BMW patent drawing. Image public domain.The pattern above is likely not real -- it's just there for illustrative purposes. In the same fashion, the diagram below is just there for layout. In other words, you will not have a giant triangle in your hand, and no real-life gearbox looks like a geometry-class doodle. But you should be smart enough to know that.
BMW patent drawing. Image public domain.Basically, BMW is working on a manual gearbox -- shift lever, 1-2-3-4-5-6-7 gate and all -- that requires no skill to operate. I find this partly repulsive (much of the joy of a manual is in the skill required to use the gearbox properly), partly intriguing (the tech behind it is pretty cool). 

When installed in a car, this gearbox would require no clutch pedal and likely no throttle modulation when changing gears -- you'd just move the lever, albeit through a traditional manual gate. If this sounds a lot like an automatic, understand that it's only partly automated: You're still physically picking the gear engaged, albeit not directly. There is no mechanical connection between the shift lever and the transmission; the "electromechanical shift actuator" behind the gearbox itself does the cog-swapping. The gearbox is a standard manual transmission, much like the one used in BMW's electrohydraulic automated-manual SMG boxes of yore.

The "patented shifting module," as E90Post labels it, is the key here. According to the patent filing, this component uses magnetorheological fluid -- the same stuff used in many electronic adaptive damping systems, including the Delphi system found on the Cadillac CTS-V, Chevrolet Corvette ZR1 and Ferrari 599 -- to allow or block entry to specific gears. 

The obvious benefit of such a device is to keep people from grossly inappropriate shifts -- a fifth-to-first shift at 60 mph, for example, when the driver really wants third gear. But that's just a side benefit. The greater purpose is to make a 7- or even 8-speed manual more practical.

2010 BMW M3. Image courtesy BMW.
Think of it like this: The more complex you make a manual transmission, the more space you need inside it -- space for gears on shafts, yes, but also space for the shift forks that move them and the air-space pattern that the lever moves through. Since there's a physical limit to how large passenger-car transmissions can be, there's also a physical limit to how tight a given transmission's shift pattern can get. Past a certain point, you can cram more gears onto an input or output shaft, but you cannot create space for shift rods to move inside the transmission casing. This is why the shift pattern on a 4- or 5-speed manual -- the space the shift lever moves through both in the transmission itself and in the cockpit -- is often tighter than that of a 6- or 7-speed manual. 

BMW manual-transmission shift lever. Image courtesy BMW.Confused? Here's a simpler answer: Porsche engineers once told me that the 7-speed manual stretches the limits of a traditional casing. With an 8-speed, the gears would be so close together, and the shifter moving in such a narrow space, that most people wouldn't be able to reliably tell, say, third gear from fifth. You'd go for one gear and get another.

BMW's design aims to circumvent that by having a machine do the actual shifting. It should allow for a practical 8-speed manual, which is cool; more gears equal better fuel economy, even if there's a limit to the gain. (Porsche's 7-speed manual, for example, has a seventh gear that is tall enough to be pointless for anything other than highway cruising. If you need real acceleration, you have to downshift two, three or even four gears.)

Regardless, this is interesting. If BMW's idea happens, it'll bring about the skill-free manual transmission. It's also the kind of thing I like to see -- a carmaker acknowledging that driver involvement and entertainment are just as important as performance. As much as I bemoan the waning of the 3-pedal car, a manual without a clutch pedal is better than none at all.

Sam Smith is a journalist, a southerner, and a reformed Alfa Romeo mechanic who spends most of his time mooning over ancient racing cars and small-batch bourbon. A multiple International Automotive Media award-winner, he has written for Automobile Magazine, Car and Driver, and Esquire, among other publications. He once drove 4,000 miles in a weekend for a hamburger and has only been threatened by the German police twice.

[Source: E90Post.com]
< Back to Exhaust Notes
User Picture
Write a comment...
26Comments
D. H.
Jun 12, 2012 6:14AM
avatar
I remember my parents having a VW Karmann Ghia with and electric clutch, just had to keep your hands off the shift lever when not actually shifting.
Vegas Teamster
Jun 11, 2012 3:38PM
avatar
The old AMC/Rambler E-stick transmission failure comes to mind every time I see something about a manually shifted trans without using a clutch.
Jmeyers
Jun 11, 2012 12:56PM
avatar
Renault had this back in the 1960's... this is nothing new except more gears... and when the electronic clutch went out! Good luck!!! lol
Lamar Wilson
Jun 11, 2012 11:54AM
avatar
This is not new tech. The 2008-current M3 has a 7 speed DCT transmission. It's a dual clutch computer shifting manual that can be shifted with paddles/stick, or put in automatic mode. I know what your thinking, it's nothing like a steptronic transmission. It can shift faster than any human being.
Someone
Jun 10, 2012 9:22AM
avatar
nice car
http://gfacebook.in

10nmbri
Jun 8, 2012 2:53PM
avatar

Don’t we already have it; it is called an automatic transmission.

Annatar
Jun 8, 2012 2:34PM
avatar
"So, at a stoplight with 100 stopped cars, 7 people are depressing clutches to start moving."

Or how about this: of 100 vehicles at a traffic light, only seven are not distracted drivers.
September the 11
Jun 8, 2012 11:35AM
avatar

In this I see the answer to the plague of the distracted driver.  Ever tried to drive a manual in a stop-n-go setting while using a phone or trying to eat a hamburger?  One hand for the wheel, one for the shifter and one for the...? Wait, my toes are too far away to hold my phone!  I have read many times that less than 7% of US cars sold in the late part of last decade were manuals.  So, at a stoplight with 100 stopped cars, 7 people are depressing clutches to start moving.  Or, a more cynical way to look at it, on the highway you take to get from your gated HOA neighborhood to the freeway, you and the 8 other drivers stuck behind the sluggard at the head of the line are probably all texting, getting Twit updates or voyering in on your "friends'" status updates because the chances are high that NONE of you have to use your extra hand to shift.  And that pathetic driver up ahead that's slowing everyone down?  He spilled his coffee in his lap because he was watching something on YouTube that caused him to crack up and swerve towards the shoulder - because, you guessed it - he had a free hand to browse the internet on his smartphone.

 

In a driving utopia, the only cars that would be available for the public to buy would be either the standard 3-pedal manual or the electronic-clutch manual as described above.  The automated-clutch manual would replace the torque converter auto and the dreaded CVT for those without the coordination to operate a clutch, forcing all drivers to keep a both hands engaged and, by extension, both eyes and their brains in the driving experience.  No more torque converters also has the benefit of increased mpgs, since the converter bleeds off energy until lockup. 

Bring it on BMW!

spillerbd
Jun 8, 2012 10:47AM
avatar

Okay, lets read the reference material from E90Post.com.... The biggest and primary part of the information there is NOT ABOUT the clutch. That is indicated as a secondary consideration.

 

The primary goal is to allow more gears in the shiftgate and locking out bad choices. By using a electro-mechanical connetion instead of a cables or levered connection from the shift lever to the gear-box, BMW hopes to allow more gears and prevent accidental damage. They will be able to devote less spess in the cabin for the gear-shift, and it will be free of the mechanical resistence physical linkages.

DXZ8643
Jun 8, 2012 8:00AM
avatar
I don't see this "innovation" as that different from the single clutch SMG gearbox that had failed miserably in the E46 model M3 and the E60 model M5.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

EXPLORE NEW CARS

MORE ON MSN AUTOS

The future of alternative propulsionThe future of alternative propulsion

A look at what could power your next car

ABOUT EXHAUST NOTES

Cars are cool, and here at MSN Autos we love everything about them, but we also know they're more than simply speed and style: a car is an essential tool, a much-needed accessory to help you get through your day-to-day life. What you drive is also one of the most important investments you can make, so we'll help you navigate your way through the car buying and ownership experiences. We strive to be your daily destination for news, notes, tips and tricks from across the automotive world. So whether it's through original content from our world-class journalists or the latest buzz from the far corners of the Web, Exhaust Notes helps you make sense of your automotive world.

Have a story idea? Tip us off at exhaustnotes@live.com.