NewUsed

Find by category:

Exhaust Notes

Supercars: What Makes a Good One?

With exotic cars, taste counts as much as price or performance.

By Sam Smith Aug 8, 2011 6:29AM
(2012 Pagani Huayura Exhaust. Image credit Ronald Ahrens/Automobile Magazine.)Horacio Pagani unveiled his 700-horsepower, 230-mph 2012 Pagani Huayra in Los Angeles last week. As supercars go, this was a significant moment. Pagani has not been making cars for long, and the greatest symbol of its success, the Pagani Zonda, is so rare that most people have never seen one. The Huayra is the brand's next step, a million-plus-dollar jewel of an automobile that should carry Pagani's company for several years. 

Only here's the thing: I cannot seem to get excited about it. Or even worked up beyond a passing interest. 

By and large, this is not important. I am neither wealthy nor part of Pagani's target market. But the appearance of a supercar that I don't immediately want -- and yet, crucially, find to be in incredibly good taste -- got me thinking: This is odd, and ultimately indefinable, stuff. What is it that makes a no-holds-barred automobile desirable? This isn't a matter of good looks or pure speed; if it were, few supercar manufacturers would go out of business. If you're buying an impractical, million-dollar car, what gets you off the couch?

(2012 Pagani Huayra. Image credit Automobile Magazine.)Above: The 2012 Pagani Huayra. Yes, it kind of looks like a Zonda. No, the rich folk do not care.

Put another way, you'd think that anything with this much power and speed would be an automatic yes-button for everyone. But it's not. People get more divided and emotional about supercars than almost anything else automotive, which strikes me as a little odd. Maybe it has something to do with dreams and how they differ from person to person (one man's fantasy is another man's nightmare, and so on), but supercars aren't universal.

Exhaust Notes editor Josh Condon has an interesting take on the matter: 
"I'm of the thought that people use the far fringe of a subject to justify their mainstream tastes -- as much to define what their tastes aren't as what they are. You see this with supermodels: One guy says Chrissy Teigen is perfection, another guy says perfection can't have a forehead that big, perfection is Kate Upton; another guy says no blonde can be the perfect woman, and so on.

Thing is, at any given time it's always the same five Victoria's Secret/Sports Illustrated models (or cars) in the conversation. People are basically using a handful of well-known examples to argue their preference for the archetypes of beauty -- exotic versus girl-next-door versus classic versus vixen, etc."
You could write all this off to taste, but there's more to it than that. If it were simply a matter of What You Like, then there wouldn't be glories like the McLaren F1 or a 1950s Ferrari Testa Rossa -- cars that are almost universally loved and lusted after. No woman is universally loved, no art exists that everyone finds appealing.

So what is it? What's most important here? What makes a high-performance car memorable? What pushes your buttons?

[Source: Automobile]

12Comments
Aug 9, 2011 4:04AM
avatar
Several seasons back on Top Gear, The Hamster posed this question and concluded that it went beyond the basic qualifications of top tier performance figures and design, but had to include the element of exclusivity and the intangible ( often hated ) "gotta have it" factor. Something completely impractical that speaks to your inner 12 year old.
Aug 8, 2011 10:52AM
avatar
Sorry the R8 TDI got canceled though.

I had to think about this one for awhile.  For me, I prefer stark simplicity.  So for me there are a few choices.  There is the V8 powered Caterham Seven, which is a modern take on the classic Lotus 7 using a small displacement V8 (2.0L to 2.6L depending on the configuration) made from two Japanese 4 cylinder motorcycle engines.  About 340HP at somewhere around 10,500 RPM.  0 to 60 in less than 3 seconds.  Nothing around you but a tinker toy frame.

The next I might choose the original Ariel Atom with the Honda K20 engine.  Another I might pick is the KTM Xbow.  Reasons for these picks are similar to the Caterham above. 

Nov 17, 2012 8:18PM
avatar

The Eye Of The Beholder,

Like a sensuous woman, an incredible piece of art or even the most exotic locale on the planet, the esoterics of supercars are in the eye of the beholder. While statospheric prices, performance and exclusivity seem to go hand in hand, the lust factor is always quite another matter. Personally, I have preferred the stealth-like angular geometry of the Lambos, the sculptural stance of the Astons and the artful flowing lines of a Lotus or Ferrari. However, for pure 'machismo' and unadultered in-your-face looks and G-force numbers, the Bugatti Veyron16.4 would seem to be the closest thing to a "Holy s**t, this thing is giving me a giant woody" experience. It would definitely be a machine to put a smile on one's face by stabbing the pedal, listening to that massive 4 turbo engine spool up and ripping through the gears on a scenic stretch of asphalt...what a rush.

Peace to all ~

Aug 8, 2011 11:01AM
avatar

Sorry Annatar, putting a diesel engine in a supercar doesn't really challenge any norms for me.  People have attempted to put diesel engines in race cars for years.  Audi is just the first company to be successful with it on the track, and transferred the technology to the consumer market.  Seems like business as usual to me, so what did it challenge?

 

When it comes to supercars, what makes them desireable isn't the technology behind the engine, or the fact that it's different than the rest of them.  If this was true, the Gumpert Apollo would be more desireable than most Ferraris.  And, at this point in the evolution of supercars, they are all very similar in terms of performance (200+ mph top speed, 0-60 in under 4 seconds, etc), so that no longer really plays a part of it anymore.

 

For me, the best supercars have something unique about their design that makes you want them in a viceral way.  The Pagani Zonda has this.  The Huarya doesn't.

Aug 9, 2011 4:55AM
avatar

Yup, I think the Hamster hit the nail on the head. For me, it's about looks and sound, and also a little rarity. I think for the most part, super, (or hyper, as TopGear has been calling the newest breed of insanely fast cars) cars are just silly. In exchange for being ludicrously expensive, the major thing they offer in return is a level of performance that except for the select few, will never be able to be (legally) exploited. I understand the "look at me" aspect of them, but personally I like something a bit more understated.

 

My "gotta have it" car would be an Aston. I don't care that there are cars that are much faster, to me the Aston is art on wheels. I don't consider it a supercar though, more of a GT, and at under 200k it's a relative bargain compared to some of them.

 

My "supercar" choice would be the Corvette ZR1. Being the Corvette hatchback bodystyle, it has some semblance of practicallity, and respectable fuel mileage for a 638hp V8. Also, at first glance it's just a Corvette, so it's a bit understated as compared to a Lambo, Zonda, or Koenigsegggegggegg. And the performance value is a downright steal compared to some others in will run with. And being a GM V8, it's only a few tweaks away from 700, or even 8 or 900 hp.

 

Annatar, you're right the TDI R8 is impressive, but I think it comes down to more than just specs and engineering details. And personally, the looks of the R8 do nothing for me.

Aug 8, 2011 1:45PM
avatar
What makes a supercar a Supercar, Imho, is that just as No woman is universally loved, and just as no art exists that everyone finds appealing, both may be loved be You and a select few others. So it's your responsibility to find those who You Love but with the full and complete understanding beforehand, that neither are going to be easy to keep happy and maintain in order for you to, at the end of the day, get the full satisfaction that you've wanted to out of them, while you've pleased them as well. which btw, is why I believe, that Ferrari, Lamborghini, Maserati, McLaren, Porsche (but for a few models) and alike, no longer Make Supercars, save the bhp and performance numbers that they deliver. well whoopee. Because again, a "Supercar" Imho, consists of what once was a Ferrari's, Maserati's, Lamborghini's or Porsche's etc gearbox and an actual clutch too. So you had to Work to get the most out of those cars. Whatsmore, there was no such thing as launch, traction control, or a Land Rover's sort of 4WD (NOT the slickly renamed AWD), which is kind of like calling a car pre-owned v. used.

So they were not only impractical, six-digit $ cars, but they were dangerous to your physical health cars as well. Or, in short, NO, had the cellphone been available in 79', you Wouldn't  have had the luxury of making a call or of texting a buddy from your 911 Turbo at triple-digit speeds, because that car Would've Bitten you..and Hard. you Will respect me. lol! but today, they'll just throw an auto-gearbox, some flappy paddles and the rest of their auto-pilot X-Box tech toys into a Supercar, along w/an F1 badge on its tail end, and the buyer's then good to go, thinking he's a Schumacher. Lol!  
Aug 8, 2011 11:55AM
avatar
Without an engine, nobody will be going anywhere. The engine is the most important innovation and technology in a vehicle, any vehicle. If you had a starship, the anti-gravity, faster-than-light drive is what would make it or break it.
Maybe for vehicles in general, but it's a stretch I think.  For cars in specific though I disagree.  The most important technology for a car is less glamorous, less fascinating, and more mysterious than the engine.  It's the tire.  Followed by the suspension and brakes.  Followed by the engine.

Though I guess if I think about it, all those pieces are actually in a way all part of the same drive system of this particular vehicle; the car.

Aug 11, 2011 4:33AM
avatar
What makes a supercar super? Just like A'holes,everyone has their own opinion as to what makes one. Is it price? speed,handling,looks,stopping power? all of the above? Speed is ok but the speed limits in the US stops most people from from really opening up. Any car can do the speed limit. Handling-well most sport or muscle cars is pretty decent at that. Looks-there are a lot of good looking cars out there. Brakes-most cars have pretty good brakes nowadays.Oh yea I forgot, how about HP? Any good sport or muscle car will be pushing 400+ hp.So that leaves price. Any so called supercar will cost you at the very least $250k which unfortunatlly only a few can afford. So I guess price is what makes a supercar super and I say that because you can buy a (for instance) shelby mustang which I think cost about $52k,put about another $15k-$20 and you'll have some of the best braking,800+hp,world class handling,good looks,speed and, and you'll have less than $80k tied up in the car. That's my opinion.
Aug 8, 2011 6:34AM
avatar
An unconventional car, designed specifically to challenge well-accepted norms and practices. A car that goes against "industry best practice", if you will, against what is considered to be acceptable... or fashionable.  A car that sets a new trend, turns a new page.

Example: Audi R8 TDI. When was the last time you could accelerate from 0-62 MPH in 4.2 seconds, had 738 lb. ft. of torque at only 1,750 RPM, and got 28 MPG, in a Euro 6 / Tier 2 bin 5 package?

Except for the R8 TDI, none of these exotic supercars challenge anything: if you look at their traits, they are all along the same lines of thinking. And in that, they are all mediocre; status quo.

When was the last time you saw a car with a turbine (not jet!) for an engine? You know, like that Chrysler from the '60s of the last century, which shattered the technology barrier?
Aug 8, 2011 11:52AM
avatar
Sorry the R8 TDI got canceled though.
So sorry. It would have been my next car.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

ABOUT EXHAUST NOTES

Cars are cool, and here at MSN Autos we love everything about them, but we also know they're more than simply speed and style: a car is an essential tool, a much-needed accessory to help you get through your day-to-day life. What you drive is also one of the most important investments you can make, so we'll help you navigate your way through the car buying and ownership experiences. We strive to be your daily destination for news, notes, tips and tricks from across the automotive world. So whether it's through original content from our world-class journalists or the latest buzz from the far corners of the Web, Exhaust Notes helps you make sense of your automotive world.

Have a story idea? Tip us off at exhaustnotes@live.com.